Tool use in ecology — conservatism & risk-taking

Why and when do ecologists adopt new tools — statistics, editors, workflows, systems, social networks? Obviously there is variation among ecologists — some adopt very early, others but those who adopt early are not only the first to reap the benefits; they also shape how their community uses and views these tools.

I’ve been thinking of this a lot lately, as I returned from the 2013 ESA. At the conference I was making new friends, meeting folks from Twitter, getting enthusiastic about nerdy things — all as per usual — and I tweeted about it:

And then there was controversy, and discussion, in the course of which I was branded <gasp!> a hipster (though not, it should be noted, for the first time:)

Caught Pabst-Handed

the author, at left, with a PBR at a local show. Brasstronaut in fact. You probably haven’t heard of them. Photo by Lewis Kelly

Markdown vs Word — a calmer, quieter Editor War?

Markdown itself has been defended already by better writers than I in these comments. There are lots of places to go to read about markdown. For example, Karthik Ram has several posts devoted to it — of which his “how to ditch Word” was most influential to me (e.g. I modelled my shell script on his).

You know what this reminds me of most? The great Editor War between emacs and Vi. Fellow ecologists — lets try to avoid starting our own, more underwhelming Editor war. Will we start referencing the “Holy Orthodoxy of Word”, or the “Zealous Cult of Markdown” or whatever? Face it, folks: the GNU/Linux community was there well ahead of us, and went way farther than we would.

The “You make me want to throw up” effect

Days after all this was happening, I found this excellent piece by Inger Mewburn. In it she describes the (sometimes scornful) reactions of her colleagues to her blogging. It struck me that a lot of content from that discussion could be copy-and-pasted into this one (maybe with a search&replace to change “blogging” -> “Markdown”):

This is quite true, but I still think the incentive structure is only part of the answer. Reluctance and determined avoidance may have multiple causes. The emotions that surround scholarly work are rarely attended to, but they are complex; ranging from curiosity and excitement to fear and envy and every stop in between. This volatile mix extends into online spaces.

Some of Dr. Mewburn’s colleagues really didn’t like that she was blogging. They thought it was frivolous, a waste of time, ‘unscholarly’. As she points out in the above quotation, the reasons people have for pushing back on a new tool can be really complicated. She compares the reactions she gets to her own feeling about the ‘cool kids’ in high school and, in my favourite quote, asks “have I become the cool kid? Am I witnessing a similar set of complex emotions, but from the other side?”

I was also reminded (HT Ethan White) of the classic TED talk featuring the first follower, that critical individual that turns a movement from an oddity to an event:

Whenever a new tool or technique comes along, we see some ecologists adopt it with zeal, some who eagerly follow the first, and others who hang back, saying “What’s in it for me”, “show me how this will improve my science first” etc. I think a study of how and why scientists adopt new techniques would be fascinating (as has been done already at CERN and I understand at NCEAS as well).

“Use what works for you” & the risks of novelty

One might argue that you can “Use what works for you” — select the tools that fit what your needs are right now. The alternative approach is to take the risk to invest time & effort in a new tool — and find your needs & mindset changing around it. Most of us are somewhere between these two extremes, though I think I’m more a proponent of taking a few risks and gaining the opportunity for serendipity.

You can’t really know, before you start learning a tool, how it is going to affect you, or your workflow. It is a risk, therefore, to adopting any new tool — the earlier, the riskier. You may waste a day, a week — or much more! — learning that technique, with no guarantee it will be useful once you do it. But you are risking something more important than your time: you’re risking your habits, your routine, even your worldview. Because you have no way of knowing, before you learn, how the New Thing is going to change your career.

For example, learning R didn’t just change the way I estimate parameters — it transformed how I collect, organize, and think about data. Learning git didn’t just help me version control my existing projects — it suggested a radical new way of organizing project directories. I’m sure that once I learn Python, Jekyll, SQL or whatever that my outlook will be changed again.

Early adopters determine the way a new tool is used by their community. Take github as an example. Look at Tim Poisot, who is soliciting comments on a preprint via his manuscript’s github issues page. Or look at Daniel Falster, writing an argument for opening up the massive TRY plant trait database and wants to know what you think about it. Is this the future of science? It might be! But if it becomes so it’ll be because these early adopters got up there and started dancing — not because they were using what had always worked for them in the past.

52 thoughts on “Tool use in ecology — conservatism & risk-taking

  1. I don’t think most scientists actually wonder “how will this improve my science” when they’re criticizing something like markdown or github or preprint servers, though they may say those words. They may _want_ to mean that, but by science they actually mean career by which they mean papers for other scientists in expensive journals that look good on their CVs.

    I think many scientsts are a little nervous about new techniques popping up because they’re afraid of losing prestige or falling behind. Academic scientists have a lot invested in a certain system and get really upset when it’s disrupted. Something like markdown can elicit weirdly disproportionate responses because it’s so tied to open science folks. The academy is hard and people are tired and then there are all these folks who seem to have time to learn these shiny new skills that let them play the game by different rules – or maybe even change the game.

    Unfortunately, there are still institutional barriers that often keep “will this help me do science in a way that will speed up or otherwise improve my field?” and “will this help my career as a scientist?” from having the same answer.

  2. Do you have a spam problem on this site; I also am a blogger,
    and I was wanting to know your situation; we have
    developed some nice procedures and we are looking to swap solutions with others,
    why not shoot me an email if interested.

  3. I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post
    was great. I do not know who you are but definitely you’re going to a famous blogger if you are not already 😉 Cheers!

  4. hello!,I love your writing very so much! share we keep
    in touch more about your post on AOL? I need an expert in this house to unravel my problem.
    May be that’s you! Looking ahead to look you.

  5. Watching online movies is the one of the newest web trends that is
    increasing with each passing day. You can read online reviews online information concerning
    some of the best Websites Online. Since you’re interested in watching online movies on television, you do not want to compromise on the Internet connection speed part.

  6. The Marketplace Investigation and Talking to division of
    O’Connor And Associates provides information necessary to
    make choice to industrial real estate experts.
    One particular in the obstacles to mentoring could be the thought of seeking the time to accomplish it.
    They possibly can continue beneath the existing system,
    or they’re capable of make an effort to easily simplify issues
    and choose to pay a flat 15 Per cent tax straight up.

  7. Plus it can give us some laughs as well if you ask it the right questions.
    In the case of a touchscreen device, the two components would be the user who is navigating the device and the screen itself.
    3 megapixel front facing camera, a feature which the Lumia
    800 lacks altogether.

  8. You can receive a monthly payment plus a line of credit.
    Basically, they want to purchase more than what they earn. You do have to pay interest,
    closing costs, and other fees.

  9. A better means would be to solely give attention to learning for one
    section at a time, do the examination for that part, take a break, after which start finding out for the next part and
    so on. Another suggestion can be to go for probably the most troublesome section first (the one that
    is most difficult for you – it will differ from person to person), because when you pass your first
    section, you only have 18 months to go the opposite three sections.

  10. Thanks for some other informative web site. The place else may just I get that kind of information written in such
    a perfect method? I’ve a mission that I am just now operating
    on, and I have been on the glance out for such info.

  11. Admiring the persistence you put into your blog and in depth
    information you provide. It’s awesome to come across a blog every
    once in a while that isn’t the same outdated rehashed information. Fantastic read!
    I’ve saved your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to
    my Google account.

  12. Magnificent items from you, man. I’ve consider your stuff
    prior to and you are simply too excellent. I really like what
    you’ve got right here, certainly like what you are saying and the way through which you are saying it.

    You make it enjoyable and you continue to take care of to keep it
    wise. I can’t wait to read far more from you. That
    is really a terrific site.

    My webpage … [Business Tips](http://cidrapbusiness.biz “Business Tips”)

  13. This is because there is a plethora of Linux distributions out
    there from which you can choose from – Ubuntu,
    Red Hat, Fedora, Mandriva, Opensuse, and so on. If the USB ports on your computer
    aren’t working and you are comfortable with attempting
    your own repair then start by checking the following:
    . Make a check for such installations and uninstall them quickly.

  14. The all is totally a superb incredibly wonderful title features a few delightfully surfing around candies, a
    pleasant popular music combined with proper performance which shall make any you feeling awfully quite by having regards returning to you.
    It has been created for the individuals who doesn’t want
    to spen any money on the game however desires to play it without end.
    This is the way this game rakes in cash although
    remaining “totally free”, and it can be an advertising and marketing technique which has worked amazingly well extremely nicely.

    my webpage … [candy crush saga astuce](https://www.facebook.com/AstucesCandyCrushSagaTricheHackCheats “candy crush saga astuce”)

  15. Very good blog! Do you have any tips and hints for aspiring
    writers? I’m hoping to start my own blog soon but I’m a little lost on everything.
    Would you suggest starting with a free platform like
    Wordpress or go for a paid option? There are so many options out there
    that I’m completely confused .. Any tips? Thanks!

  16. She was saying words she had learned from the
    books. Burke struggled to find his rhythm, hitting only 1-8 from the floor.

    “It could be in the picture where, if you have a person with autism and who has some degree of intellectual disability, and you see also they have large runs of homozygosity, then together you could say that constellation of symptoms might help us predict that they’d be less responsive to conventional treatments and we’d have to discern a new treatment pathway.

    my website … [criminal case astuce](https://www.facebook.com/AstucesCriminalCaseTricheHackCheats “criminal case
    astuce”)

  17. I blog often and I truly thank you for your content.
    Your article has really peaked my interest.
    I will take a note of your website and keeep checking
    for new information about oncxe per week. I opted in for your
    Feeed too.

    Lookk at my homepagge … [m88](http://eis.cx/m88293847 “m88”)

  18. He served as a tank commander during the first Gulf War and was honorably discharged in 1992.

    Also, do not try to use this against the GLA angry mob as their Molotov cocktails can destroy it within seconds.

    Their alter could be connected to cybernetic clones in underground facilities via satellite and implant technology.

    my web site … [war commander triche](https://www.facebook.com/AstucesWarCommanderTricheHackCheats “war commander triche”)

  19. In order to know how much the option price will estimate, binary option calculator is also available.
    Such digital currency is not controlled by a central bank and has actually been around for the last four years.
    So long as banks and financial firms are hungry for new business
    you can be sure they will cook up some scheme to catch the
    curious and unwary. In essence, if you want to make money when trading,
    it’s best to stick to the basics. Shares can be obtained from various binary options brokers.

    In the event the investor is incorrect, he gets zero.

  20. Thank you a lot for sharing this with all people you actually know what
    you are talking about! Bookmarked. Kindly additionally discuss with my site
    =). We may have a hyperlink alternate arrangement among us

  21. Firewalling, Intrusion Protection Systems, Anti –
    Virus software and fully implemented device hardening measures will still not stop
    or even detect a rogue employee who works as an ‘inside man’.
    Step6: Reboot computer and login to the locked PC without password.

    The reason behind having multiple email accounts is based on the
    fact that if your single email account is taken then the
    individual who has that account can have all your passwords send to that account
    for reset.

    My homepage; [farmville 2 trucos](https://es-es.facebook.com/TrucosFarmville2HackCheatsTrucos “farmville 2 trucos”)

  22. A website that can attract more visitors would generally have the greater chance of
    profiting in affiliate marketing programs. Then, write a short ad copy
    that lays more emphasis on the product’s benefits. The consultants of
    Internet marketing help its clients in increasing the web traffic over their internet sites.
    Normally, when you recycle a product it will not be used for the same reason again, it will
    normally be turned into something different.
    ” Tony Laidig demonstrated how to make book trailers using video and Karon Thackston took time to help attendees with landing pages and SEO. These are user actions by which you will get commissions on different rates.

  23. The benefits of this detox is to obviously rid the body
    of harmful toxins, such as preservatives and food additives together with inhaled smoke and fumes.
    In many cases, a diet coach is someone that has been overweight themselves and can fully understand
    the magnitude of your weight loss struggle. During this period, the only rule is not to adhere to the specified meal plan.

  24. Exclusively at Target: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 2 Blu-ray
    Combo Pack that includes the following bonus 44-minute documentary special
    feature “When Harry Left Hogwarts”. Also known as the ‘Southern Sasquatch’ and “Boggy Creek Monster,” the creature
    was frequently sighted near the town of Fouke, Arkansas, during the
    early 1970s. Battles operate in a comparable way as in monster City.

  25. Spot on with this write-up, I truly believe this web site needs much more
    attention. I’ll probably be back again to see more, thanks for the advice!

  26. ‘ It’s one of the most addictive games of the smart phone-era,
    with people spending an estimated $633,000 per day
    on the King-produced game. It’s a soup of gastronomic proportions with giant meatballs and spaghetti
    tornadoes pleasing the child in all of us. These
    colors can be layered but I wouldn’t recommend wearing them on the lips without a layer of lip balm or salve.

    My page: [trucos para el candy crush saga](https://es-es.facebook.com/TrucosCandyCrushSagaHackCheatsTrucos “trucos para el candy crush saga”)

  27. Search and research all the keywords that have an interest in your site theme.

    And, never, ever wait until your customer leaves
    or threatens to leave and then offer them the world to stay.
    However, if another user with Administrator privileges then accesses these same servers and re-enables the Guest Account for any reason, you will then be
    left exposed.

    my website … [trucchi marvel avengers](https://it-it.facebook.com/TrucchiPerMarvelAvengersAllianceTrucco “trucchi marvel avengers”)

  28. Hi! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site before but after reading through some of the post I realized it’s new to me.
    Nonetheless, I’m definitely delighted I found it and I’ll be bookmarking and checking back frequently!

  29. The staff is equipped to provide traders with the latest and most useful tips to
    aid them in their decision for investments. Please click the SUBSCRIBE button at the top to receive email updates of new
    articles from Tomica Bonner. If a backtest of a
    strategy shows less than 100% in a year then it is necessary to keep looking for a better trading
    system. Depending upon asset you choose to invest in, you can earn some serious amount of money.

    You will be able to generate fantastic profit with it as well.
    The Binary Options Broker is a Web site that offers reviews of various online binary options online platforms.

  30. ) Classic wool pants to die for a great pair of wool pants is
    perfect for a day at the office or a night at a lovely.
    Some materials like Gore-tex gives snow boots a reliable and water-proof quality in which surely no
    liquid will slip inside. We often don’t pay much attention to the different elements
    of the corporate uniform, considering that not much can be done to make our workwear more stylish or more comfortable.

  31. One of the reasons that people don’t speak out is because they
    know if they do speak out they’ll be ostracized. The next thing you’ll find important are Gold, these will
    be used to also build things and get special items you will need to move in the game itself.
    And work some more when in the comfort of our own home.

  32. What i don’t understood is in reality how you’re now not really much more neatly-favored than you might be
    now. You’re so intelligent. You recognize therefore significantly
    relating to this topic, produced me in my opinion believe it from a lot of numerous angles.
    Its like men and women aren’t involved until it is something to
    accomplish with Girl gaga! Your own stuffs nice.

    All the time handle it up!

Comments are closed.